Caixin
Jan 07, 2021 08:44 PM
BUSINESS & TECH

In Depth: Online Learning Specialists Burning Cash as Fast as They Can Raise It

Investors are betting big on China‘s online education sector in the wake of Covid-19, but huge marketing costs mean that losses are growing.
Investors are betting big on China‘s online education sector in the wake of Covid-19, but huge marketing costs mean that losses are growing.

After the pandemic drove demand for remote services of all kinds, Chinese online education companies are building their war chests for another round of fierce competition, which investors say will likely continue until one emerges as the industry’s dominant player.

After-school tutoring startup Yuanfudao told Caixin it had secured $300 million in a December financing round, on the eve of Chinese schools’ one-month winter holiday, when demand for online education spikes.

The latest funding comes just two months after its valuation hit $1.5 billion in the wake of a $2.2 billion series G round. That valuation was more than twice the figure from a year earlier and made it the world’s most valuable education unicorn, as investors bet on the Beijing-based operator of live tutoring and online homework platforms.

The company’s U.S.-listed rivals such as GSX Techedu Inc. and TAL Education Group are also rushing to raise fresh cash, even as the requirement to spend big on marketing means any chance of a profit remains remote — indeed losses are widening.

“You have to spend two bucks before you earn a dime,” Michael Yu, founder and president of the after-school tutoring agency New Oriental Education and Technology Group Inc., said in a speech last month. The sector saw $15 billion of investment last year, but only had revenue of a few billion dollars, he said.

If you don’t raise money when everyone else is, you’ll fall behind, said Liu Zhanxiang, an education analyst at investment bank China Renaissance Holdings Ltd. “Even though there is abundant money coming into the online education sector from investors, the strong players are likely to get stronger, and the weaker ones will get weaker,” he said.

Losses widened

Online education companies are often spending 1.5 times their sales revenue on reaching new customers and managing their operations, according to Yu Jinyong, the co-founder of education-focused investment firm Z-Edu.

All e-learning companies’ marketing costs make up more than half of total spending, and profits will only come when this falls under half, Yu said. However, a constant supply of new customers is necessary as student retention remains a problem, with less than a third sticking with an online education provider for over a year.

The companies are mostly reporting strong sales growth. The online school unit of TAL Education, Xueersi Online School reported over 2.9 million classes “without discount” were sold during the 2019 summer holiday from June to August, up about 100% from the year earlier. Middle- and elementary-school tutoring platform Mishumao.com said it saw 350% growth over the same period, selling 1.7 million classes.

But it can be difficult to gauge how many students these numbers represent, as the companies only release data about the number of classes sold. This is likely significantly higher than actual student numbers as people tend to attend multiple classes.

Also, the key metric is not how many classes are sold, but how many are sold at a normal price. Sales figures are subject to manipulation, as companies often sell them at a significant discount. GSX Techedu counts all classes sold for over 99 yuan ($15.33), a far lower threshold than most other companies, industry players said.

Student numbers have also been subject to fraud allegations, with short-seller Muddy Waters claiming in August last year that some 80% of GSX Techedu users were bots and it was vastly overstating its revenue. Those allegations led to a probe from the U.S. regulator.

GSX’s third quarter revenue of 1.99 billion yuan represented a deceleration of year-on-year growth to 252.9%, compared with 461.5% growth in the third quarter in 2019. It reported a 933 million yuan loss that quarter, down from a small profit the year earlier. In the following fourth quarter of 2020, it said profits grew 658.7% to 175 million yuan on revenue of 935 million yuan

Xueersi also posted weaker-than-expected revenue growth last year, recording its smallest expansion of just 87% in the third quarter. It had hoped for triple-digit growth, Chief Financial Officer Luo Rong said in July.

Youdao Inc., an online education subsidiary of internet giant NetEase Inc., experienced a loss of 878 million yuan in the third quarter, widening from a 242 million yuan shortfall the previous year. New Oriental saw its loss increase more than 10 times to 758 million yuan.

Financing race

Despite these losses, the sector is still flush with cash as school closures due to the Covid-19 pandemic have driven investor enthusiasm.

Out of the 10 education service companies that secured the most investment in the first half of 2020, nine are online education agencies, according to data provider Beijing Tianyancha Technology Co. Ltd.

More than three quarters of the new funding for Chinese e-learning companies last year went to Yuanfudao and Mishumao.com, according to Tianyancha.

In 2020, Yuanfudao took in $3.5 billion. Mishumao.com planning a new round of financing that will be announced soon, inside sources told Caixin, Mishumao.com’s last valuation was $6.5 billion after a $750 million series E round in June last year.

U.S.-listed TAL Education said in November that it would sell $1.5 billion of yuan-denominated shares to an investment firm. GSX announced in December that a group of investors would buy $870 million of new shares in the company, which it would spend on developing classes and technology, as well as hiring more teachers.

However, people at a leading company said that most of the cash these companies are raising is not going to improving the quality of their services but is instead spend on marketing.

GSX, which has previously claimed to spend less money on marketing than its peers, increased its spending to 2.06 billion yuan in the third quarter, up from 330 million in the same period a year earlier. Youdou’s spending in the third quarter of 2020 was four times larger than in 2019, hitting 1.15 billion yuan.

“It is not normal to do business while burning through money, but my idea has changed now that the market is being restructured, so much capital flowing in,” GSX founder Chen Xiangdong said in December. “The company can tolerate losses at this stage of expansion and we need to focus on the life cycle of our customer base, instead of aiming to make a profit from the first order.”

Brick-and-mortar players

Competition in the online space is only likely to get fiercer as traditionally offline-focused players increasingly look to move online to offset a drop-off in demand at their brick-and-mortar locations.

Online education institutions also need to look out for challenges from offline competitors, if they are to survive, according to Z-Edu’s Yu.

Even though China has mostly gotten its domestic Covid-19 epidemic under control, fear of returning to classes means parents are leaning more on online extracurriculars.

U.S.-listed English tutoring company Rise Education Cayman Ltd. saw its revenue for the first three quarters of last year plunge 46.6% to 594 million yuan as its physical classrooms were shut. That saw it go from a 97 million yuan profit over the first three quarters of 2019 to a 134 million yuan loss in the same period last year.

Even though 90% of its offline courses went online, the company took on fewer students due to weaker learning outcomes in internet classes, the company’s third-quarter financial report said.

Offline education specialist New Oriental said it is pursuing an “online-merge-offline” strategy, in which it has invested $39 million. The company’s Chief Financial Officer Yang Zhihui said that this pivot had already seen its student numbers spike after rolling out online classes in over 20 cities. Yang said the company plans to expand its geographical range with further investment.

But it is not easy to bring offline courses online, Liu Zhanxiang at China Renaissance said. “Small-to-medium offline tutoring agencies without an existing online course system would have difficulties building digital infrastructure. It would be easier for big institutions to do so, but it still takes time,” Liu said.

Contact reporter Anniek Bao (yunxinbao@caixin.com) and editor Joshua Dummer (joshuadummer@caixin.com)

Download our app to receive breaking news alerts and read the news on the go.

You've accessed an article available only to subscribers
VIEW OPTIONS
Share this article
Open WeChat and scan the QR code