[Weekly Preview] Can China’s Supermarket Reshuffle Create Success? (AI Translation)
Listen to the full version

文|财新周刊 孙嫣然 包云红
By Sun Yanran and Bao Yunhong, Caixin Weekly
曾经备受电商平台追捧的线下零售资产——大型连锁超市,正在被战略性放弃。中国互联网巨头在经历十年狂飙突进投资并购后,转向整理资产剥离出售,收缩回归主营业务。
Offline retail assets, namely large chain supermarkets, which were once highly coveted by e-commerce platforms, are now being strategically abandoned. After a decade of rapid investment and acquisitions, Chinese internet giants are turning to asset divestitures and sales, scaling back to focus on their core businesses.
9月23日,家居潮玩连锁企业名创优品(NYSE:MNSO/09896.HK)突发公告收购第一大商超永辉超市(601933.SH)两大股东香港牛奶公司和京东(NASDAQ:JD/09618.HK)各自持有的21.1%、8.3%的股权,一跃成为第一大股东,交易对价62.70亿元。
On September 23, popular home and trendy retail chain Miniso (NYSE: MNSO/09896.HK) made an unexpected announcement about acquiring stakes in Yonghui Superstores (601933.SH) held by its two major shareholders, Dairy Farm International and JD.com (NASDAQ: JD/09618.HK). Miniso acquired 21.1% from Dairy Farm and 8.3% from JD.com, thereby becoming the largest shareholder with a transaction value of 6.27 billion yuan.
三天后,早已被阿里巴巴(NYSE:BABA/09988.HK)待价而沽的中国第二大商超大润发,也声称有了潜在买家。9月27日,大润发母公司高鑫零售(06808.HK)停牌,披露接到私有化要约。据财新了解,高瓴、德弘两家私募股权投资机构是潜在收购方。不过,直到目前该交易仍无实质性推进,各方噤声。
Three days later, RT-Mart, China's second-largest hypermarket chain long up for sale by Alibaba (NYSE: BABA/09988.HK), also announced a potential buyer. On September 27, Sun Art Retail Group (06808.HK), the parent company of RT-Mart, suspended its trading to disclose it had received a privatization offer. According to Caixin's sources, Hillhouse Capital and DDH Investment are the potential acquirers. However, the deal has not made any tangible progress, as all parties remain tight-lipped.
- DIGEST HUB
- Chinese internet giants, including Alibaba and JD.com, are divesting offline retail assets like supermarkets after previously investing heavily in their expansion, notably scaling back to refocus on core online businesses.
- Miniso acquired a significant stake in Yonghui Superstores, becoming its largest shareholder, while RT-Mart, another major chain, is reportedly being considered for acquisition by Hillhouse Capital and DDH Investment.
- The shift reflects a strategic response to the changing retail landscape and financial pressures, with traditional supermarkets struggling against new formats and digital competition.
Offline retail assets, like large chain supermarkets, are no longer favored by e-commerce giants, who are now offloading these in favor of core businesses. [para. 1] Miniso recently acquired 29.4% of Yonghui Superstores, becoming its largest shareholder with a transaction valued at 6.27 billion yuan. [para. 2] Alibaba is considering selling RT-Mart, with a potential offer from Hillhouse Capital and DDH Investment. [para. 3]
In the past, giants like JD.com and Alibaba made significant investments in offline retail, such as JD.com’s stake in Yonghui and Alibaba’s acquisition of Sun Art Retail Group. They aimed at integrating online and offline businesses, targeting sectors like fresh produce and consumables. [para. 4] However, the pandemic highlighted the limitations of hypermarkets, shifting focus towards instant retail and smaller store formats. [para. 5]
Both JD.com and Alibaba are now divesting from these investments. JD.com, after not achieving transformative outcomes with Yonghui, is withdrawing to focus on its core operations. Similarly, Alibaba has ended financial support for RT-Mart and Hema under new leadership. [para. 6][para. 7]
As a consequence, supermarkets like Yonghui and RT-Mart are closing stores to cut losses. Yonghui seeks to reinvent itself by collaborating with Pang Donglai, a smaller chain known for resisting common industry trends. [para. 10][para. 11] Miniso’s founder, Ye Guofu, sees this as an opportunity to revitalize Yonghui with a model focused on customer experience tailored to Chinese consumers, despite challenges in traditional retail formats. [para. 12]
The transactions have prompted mixed reactions in the stock market. Miniso’s shares fell sharply, while Yonghui's surged after the acquisition announcement. Analysts suggest concerns about the future viability of traditional retail in China. [para. 18] Yonghui’s partnership with Miniso drew skepticism, as Miniso’s experience lies outside grocery retail, and the brand has little expertise in large supermarket supply chains. [para. 22]
Despite these challenges, Miniso continues with aggressive expansion plans, especially overseas, and maintains a strategy integrating retail for both discretionary and non-discretionary goods. [para. 24] Initiatives like aligning product offerings and private label developments aim to bolster Yonghui’s competitiveness. [para. 26] However, funds for such acquisitions are a concern among investors, worrying about Miniso's ability to finance the acquisition without undermining its growth plans. [para. 28]
Supermarket chains like Sun Art Retail are undergoing transformations, including the closure of loss-making stores and restructuring into smaller formats or membership-based models. [para. 35] The new focus areas for RT-Mart include multi-format developments and prioritizing competitive pricing strategies to attract more customers. [para. 38]
Though the success of these transitions remains to be seen, as higher labor and restructuring costs pose challenges, early indications show some profitability in adjusted stores. [para. 39][para. 41] RT-Mart's transformation involves adopting membership models and refining operations, though it faces competition from established players like Sam’s Club. [para. 44] Both RT-Mart and Yonghui's future success in adapting to market demands hinges on understanding consumer needs and operational efficiency. [para. 47]
- MINISO
名创优品 - MINISO, founded in 2013 in Guangzhou, is a trendy household goods retailer benefiting from post-pandemic consumption trends and expanding rapidly overseas. In the first half of 2023, its revenue increased by 25% to 7.759 billion yuan, with a net profit of 1.17 billion yuan. MINISO plans to significantly increase its global store count by 2028 and recently acquired shares in Yonghui Superstores, aiming to leverage its expertise in consumer goods and IP marketing.
- Yonghui Superstores
永辉超市 - Yonghui Superstores is undergoing a strategic shift after divesting shares by its major stakeholders, including JD.com. Miniso has become Yonghui's largest shareholder with a 21.1% stake. To remain competitive, Yonghui is partnering with Chinese boutique supermarket chain Pang Da Lai to revamp its stores with a focus on consumer experience and product quality. However, the venture comes with high labor costs and questions about long-term profitability.
- JD.com
京东 - JD.com has strategically exited its investment in Yonghui Superstores by selling its shares to Miniso. Despite initially acquiring a stake to expand its fresh goods O2O market, collaboration with Yonghui proved ineffective, leading JD to focus on core businesses. This move included reducing its share by 11.25%, resulting in significant financial losses compared to the initial investment, as the selling price per share was much lower than the acquisition cost.
- Alibaba
阿里巴巴 - Alibaba is strategically retreating from its offline supermarket ventures. The company halted its new retail experiments after founder Jack Ma's return and CEO Daniel Zhang's departure. They have redefined traditional retail as non-core, considering exits from such businesses "very reasonable." Alibaba owned 77.02% of Sun Art (RT-Mart's parent); however, due to market conditions, its stock value plummeted, prompting ongoing discussions about potential sale options.
- RT-Mart
大润发 - RT-Mart, China's second-largest supermarket, has been undergoing restructuring as Alibaba looks to divest its stake. Potential buyers include private equity firms like Hillhouse Capital. RT-Mart has faced store closures and cost-cutting efforts, reporting a recent profit after a series of losses but still grappling with low stock valuation. Efforts include store modernization and a focus on member stores and medium-sized supermarkets to boost sales and return to profitability.
- Sun Art Retail
高鑫零售 - Sun Art Retail, the parent company of the Chinese supermarket chain RT-Mart, received a privatization offer on September 27, with Hillhouse Capital and DCP being potential buyers. Alibaba had previously controlled Sun Art following a substantial investment in 2017 and 2020. Due to declining offline supermarket performance, Alibaba seeks to exit and define traditional retail as non-core, potentially valuing Sun Art's real estate assets over its current market value.
- Costco
开市客 - The article mentions that Costco's retail model, characterized by large packaging and a warehouse-style, membership-fee approach, has been successful in China, establishing it as a benchmark in the industry. This model is contrasted with local trends, as the article suggests that smaller packaging and high-quality products may better cater to Chinese consumer preferences. Compared to Chinese retailers, Costco's scale is significantly larger.
- Sam's Club
山姆会员店 - Sam's Club is mentioned as a successful example in China, known for offering large-pack, high-quality, and low-price products through a membership model. It is highlighted as a representative of growth in the supermarket industry, contrasting with the challenges faced by traditional large supermarkets in China.
- Pangdonglai
胖东来 - Pangdonglai is a small, boutique supermarket chain based in Henan, China, with just 12 stores in Xuchang and Xinxiang. The chain is known for its unique retail approach that opposes trends like cost-cutting and price wars, focusing instead on customer and employee experience. It has garnered significant attention and is considered a role model in revitalizing traditional retail, as demonstrated by its collaboration with Yonghui Superstores for store improvements.
- 2015:
- JD.com acquired a 10% stake in Yonghui Superstores for 4.31 billion yuan.
- January 2016:
- Alibaba opened its first offline supermarket, Hema Fresh, in Shanghai's Pudong District.
- 2016:
- JD.com swapped shares with Walmart, acquiring the latter's e-commerce platform Yihaodian.
- 2017:
- Alibaba acquired a controlling stake in Sun Art Retail Group.
- 2019:
- Supermarkets that relied on real estate began to decline as the market adjusted.
- October 2020:
- Alibaba increased its stake in Sun Art Retail to 77.02% by purchasing additional shares.
- Before and During 2022 Fiscal Year:
- Sun Art Retail's revenue plummeted 29.3%, transitioning from a profit to a loss.
- February 2024:
- Alibaba's chairman Joseph Tsai categorized traditional brick-and-mortar retail as a non-core focus business.
- March 2024:
- Alibaba recalled Lin Xiaohai, the head of Retail通, back to the company.
- May 2024:
- Lin Xiaohai resigned from Alibaba.
- March and June 2024:
- JD.com reduced its stake in Yonghui Superstores twice through auctions and block trading.
- June and July 2024:
- Ye Guofu visited Yonghui's adjusted stores, initially considering purchasing only JD.com's shares.
- August 2024:
- Ye Guofu became proactive in acquiring more shares of Yonghui.
- September 23, 2024:
- Miniso announced acquisition of shares in Yonghui Superstores from Dairy Farm and JD.com.
- September 24, 2024:
- Miniso's Hong Kong shares plunged nearly 40% after the deal announcement.
- September 27, 2024:
- Sun Art Retail Group suspended its trading and announced a privatization offer.
- PODCAST
- MOST POPULAR



