Exclusive: Suning’s $28 Billion Restructuring Plan Tests China’s Approach to Corporate Failure
00:00/00:00
Listen to this article
1x
Subscribe now
Listen to the full version
Listen to the full version
In the high-rise jungle of Nanjing, the name “Suning” still glows faintly in neon on the façades of shuttered malls and half-empty office towers. Once a national symbol of entrepreneurial ambition, the retail empire that brought flat-screen TVs and air conditioners to millions of Chinese homes has become an emblem of corporate overreach—and a test case for how China handles the collapse of its private giants.
You've accessed an article available only to subscribers
VIEW OPTIONS
Unlock exclusive discounts with a Caixin group subscription — ideal for teams and organizations.
Subscribe to both Caixin Global and The Wall Street Journal — for the price of one.
- RELATED
Share this article
Open WeChat and scan the QR code
- DIGEST HUB
Digest Hub
Back
Explore the story in 30 seconds
- Suning Holdings faces $28.1 billion in debt, with 188.07 billion yuan in creditor claims and assets valued far below liabilities; most claims will be converted to trust shares, with cash repayment only for small debts and wages.
- The court-ordered restructuring carves out Suning.com under state and strategic investor control, while other core assets are transferred to a trust led operationally by founder Zhang Jindong, but creditors will own the equity.
- Ordinary creditors face significant losses, potentially recovering as little as 3.5%; creditor consensus on the plan is mixed, with a vote deadline extended to November 14, 2025.
AI generated, for reference only
Explore the story in 3 minutes
[para. 1]
AI generated, for reference only
Who’s Who
- Suning Holdings Group Co. Ltd.
- Suning Holdings Group Co. Ltd. is a Chinese retail conglomerate founded in Nanjing. Once a national symbol of entrepreneurial ambition, it faces financial distress due to rapid diversification, excessive debt-fueled expansion, and declining core business profitability. In 2025, it entered court-ordered restructuring for over 200 billion yuan ($28.1 billion) in debt. Its publicly listed e-commerce platform, Suning.com Co. Ltd., was previously separated through a state-led bailout.
- Suning Appliance Group Co. Ltd.
- Suning Appliance Group Co. Ltd. is one of the three core holding platforms of Suning Holdings Group Co. Ltd. that entered court-ordered restructuring proceedings in early 2025. It is also tied to significant claims, with Citic Trust Co. Ltd. filing a 9.99 billion yuan secured claim through its "Suning Appliance Portfolio Trust."
- Suning Real Estate Group Co. Ltd.
- Suning Real Estate Group Co. Ltd. is one of the three core holding platforms of Suning Holdings Group Co. Ltd. that entered court-ordered restructuring proceedings in early 2025. It is responsible for Suning's "heavy assets." Under the restructuring plan, it will become a wholly owned subsidiary of the newly formed New Suning Group, which will manage the remaining operational assets.
- Suning.com Co. Ltd.
- Suning.com Co. Ltd. is the publicly listed e-commerce platform and was once considered the "crown jewel" of the Suning group. It was carved out in a government-led bailout in 2020-2021, with investors like Alibaba, Haier, Midea, and Xiaomi acquiring a stake, shielding it from its parent entities' collapse. Despite this, it still carries significant liabilities.
- Alibaba Group Holding Ltd.
- Alibaba Group Holding Ltd. is a major corporate investor that acquired a 22.65% stake in Suning.com from its founder for approximately 12 billion yuan. This investment helped shield Suning.com, the e-commerce platform, from the collapse of its parent entities by providing a government-led bailout alongside other strategic investors.
- Haier Group Corp.
- Haier Group Corp. is one of the major corporate investors, alongside Alibaba Group Holding Ltd., Midea Group Co. Ltd., and Xiaomi Corp., that acquired a 22.65% stake in Suning.com from founder Zhang Jindong for approximately 12 billion yuan. This deal was part of a government-led bailout to shield Suning.com from the collapse of its parent entities.
- Midea Group Co. Ltd.
- Midea Group Co. Ltd. participated in a government-led bailout of Suning.com Co. Ltd. between late 2020 and mid-2021. Midea, alongside other major corporate investors, acquired a 22.65% stake in Suning.com from its founder, Zhang Jindong, for approximately 12 billion yuan. This intervention aimed to shield Suning.com from the collapse of its parent entities.
- Xiaomi Corp.
- Xiaomi Corp. is mentioned in the article as one of the major corporate investors, alongside Alibaba Group Holding Ltd., Haier Group Corp., and Midea Group Co. Ltd., that acquired a 22.65% stake in Suning.com from founder Zhang Jindong. This acquisition was part of a government-led bailout of Suning.com, with the investors paying approximately 12 billion yuan.
- New Suning Group
- New Suning Group is a newly formed entity under Suning's restructuring plan. It aims to oversee retained operations following the company's financial distress. It will manage Suning's five operational commercial complexes and four under-construction commercial complexes. This entity will control three wholly-owned subsidiaries: Suning Real Estate Group, Suning Commercial Life Group, and Suning Equity Management. The group's founder, Zhang, may retain operational leadership under a performance covenant.
- Suning Commercial Life Group
- Suning Commercial Life Group is a "light asset" subsidiary managing property and commercial services for Suning's remaining portfolio. It will oversee Suning's retained operations, including five commercial complexes, as part of the broader restructuring plan aiming to keep Zhang Jindong in operational control, despite creditors gaining equity ownership.
- Suning Equity Management
- Suning Equity Management is a wholly-owned subsidiary of the newly formed New Suning Group. It is tasked with overseeing Suning's remaining financial holdings. These include a 4.15% stake in the listed e-commerce platform Suning.com and partial ownership of Shanghai Xingtu Financial Services Group Co. Ltd., which holds licenses in lending, payments, and insurance brokerage. Its operations are crucial in managing the group's equity assets to repay creditors.
- Citic Financial Asset Management Co. Ltd.’s Jiangsu branch
- Citic Financial Asset Management Co. Ltd.’s Jiangsu branch is one of two state-backed asset managers expected to provide up to 8 billion yuan in common-benefit loans to restart four stalled developments under the New Suning Group, a newly formed entity overseeing Suning's retained operations.
- China Orient Asset Management Co. Ltd.’s Jiangsu branch
- The Jiangsu branch of China Orient Asset Management Co. Ltd. is one of two state-backed asset managers expected to provide crucial common-benefit loans, potentially up to 8 billion yuan, to help restart stalled commercial developments belonging to Suning. This funding is essential for the restructuring plan to proceed.
- Shanghai Suning Real Estate
- Shanghai Suning Real Estate is a subsidiary of Suning and holds a 49% stake in the Bellagio Hotel in Shanghai. This luxury riverside property is one of the assets included in the restructuring plan for Suning, though its project company creditors filed for bankruptcy in January, with the case still under review by a Shanghai court.
- Haigang Life Insurance Co Ltd.
- Haigang Life Insurance Co Ltd. (formerly China Evergrande Group’s insurance arm) is mentioned in the article as an interested party in recapitalizing the Bellagio Hotel project in Shanghai to prevent its fire sale. Suning holds a 49% stake in Shanghai Suning Real Estate, which owns the Bellagio Hotel.
- Shanghai Xingtu Financial Services Group Co. Ltd.
- Shanghai Xingtu Financial Services Group Co. Ltd. is a subsidiary of Suning, holding licenses in lending, payments, and insurance brokerage. Its ownership was included in the trust assets formed during Suning's restructuring, specifically under Suning Equity Management.
- Shanshan Group Co. Ltd.
- Shanshan Group Co. Ltd. was mentioned in the article as an example of a recent Chinese restructuring. Its restructuring included named creditor representatives, which was contrasted with Suning's current proposal that does not yet specify which creditors will sit on the trust's management committee.
- Bank of Communications Co. Ltd., Jiangsu branch
- Bank of Communications Co. Ltd., Jiangsu branch, is a major creditor of Suning Holdings Group Co. Ltd. It is a member of Suning's creditors' committee and has about 2 billion yuan in claims against the company.
- China Everbright Bank Co. Ltd., Nanjing branch
- China Everbright Bank Co. Ltd., Nanjing branch, is part of the nine-member creditors' committee for Suning Holdings Group Co. Ltd.'s restructuring. Along with other major lenders, it holds significant influence in approving the proposed plan for Suning's 200-billion-yuan debt.
- Shanghai Pudong Development Bank Co. Ltd.
- Shanghai Pudong Development Bank Co. Ltd. (SPD Bank) is listed as a member of Suning Holdings Group Co. Ltd.'s creditors' committee, specifically its Nanjing branch. SPD Bank also holds claims under court review due to pending litigation outcomes in relation to Suning's restructuring.
- Huaxia Bank Co. Ltd.
- Huaxia Bank Co. Ltd. (华夏银行股份有限公司) is a Chinese commercial bank. Its Nanjing branch is listed as a member of the creditors' committee for Suning Holdings Group Co. Ltd. restructuring. The Nanjing branch holds over 6.3 billion yuan in secured claims against Suning.
- Bank of Jiangsu Co. Ltd.
- Bank of Jiangsu Co. Ltd. is mentioned as a member of the creditors' committee in Suning's restructuring plan. It is part of a group of financial institutions, including commercial banks and asset managers, that will vote on the proposed restructuring.
- Shengjing Bank Co. Ltd.
- Shengjing Bank Co. Ltd. holds significant exposure to Suning, with 6.5 billion yuan in unsecured debt and 8.2 billion yuan in secured claims. It is one of Suning's largest exposed creditors, partly due to its past association with Evergrande.
- Industrial Bank Co. Ltd.’s Nanjing branch
- Industrial Bank Co. Ltd.’s Nanjing branch is a significant creditor of Suning. Their claims are among those under court review due to pending litigation outcomes concerning Suning's restructuring plan. The branch is part of a pool of major domestic banks with substantial exposure to Suning's debts.
- China Construction Bank Corp.
- China Construction Bank Corp. is one of the major lenders with claims against Suning. The bank's claims are still under court review due to pending litigation outcomes.
- Bank of New York Mellon Corp.
- Bank of New York Mellon Corp. has filed a 5.6 billion yuan claim against Suning, believed to be on behalf of Suning's offshore bondholders. This places it among the creditors facing potential losses in Suning's restructuring.
- Evergrande Group
- The article doesn't mention Evergrande Group in a primary role. It states that Haigang Life Insurance Co. Ltd. (formerly China Evergrande Group's insurance arm) has shown interest in recapitalizing the Bellagio Hotel in Shanghai, partly owned by Suning, to avoid a fire sale. Additionally, it notes that Suning had strategic investments with Evergrande that were not fully recovered, and Shengjing Bank, once under Evergrande's influence, is a major Suning creditor.
- Citic Trust Co. Ltd.
- Citic Trust Co. Ltd. filed a 9.99 billion yuan secured claim through its "Suning Appliance Portfolio Trust." This claim is likely structured for institutional and private investors, many of whom have faced lengthy legal disputes due to property-linked trusts amid China's real estate defaults.
- Whirlpool China Co. Ltd.
- Whirlpool China Co. Ltd. (惠而浦（中国）股份有限公司) is mentioned in the article as one of the hardest-hit small suppliers to Suning. A widely circulated letter from Whirlpool China Co. Ltd. demanding overdue payments from Suning.com highlights the growing tension and challenges faced by suppliers due to Suning's financial distress.
AI generated, for reference only
What Happened When
- By 2020：
- Suning's crisis became irreversible due to thinning home appliance retail margins and failed investments in sports clubs, real estate, and entertainment.
- 2020：
- A supplier completed renovation work at a Suning hotel and was still owed over 8 million yuan by the time of the article.
- Between late 2020 and mid-2021：
- Regulators and major corporate investors (including Alibaba, Haier, Midea, and Xiaomi) acquired a 22.65% stake in Suning.com from founder Zhang Jindong for about 12 billion yuan, as part of a government-led bailout.
- January 2025：
- Creditors of the project company holding the Bellagio Hotel in Shanghai (in which Suning owns a 49% stake) filed for bankruptcy. The case is still under review by a Shanghai court.
- Early 2025：
- Three core Suning entities (Suning Appliance Group Co. Ltd., Suning Holdings Group, and Suning Real Estate Group Co. Ltd.) entered court-ordered restructuring following a ruling by the Nanjing Intermediate People’s Court.
- As of 2025：
- The first tranche of 1.4 billion yuan in new funding from state-backed asset managers for New Suning Group has not yet been finalized.
- September 12, 2025：
- Second creditors’ meeting was held, and the restructuring proposal was presented.
- Mid-September 2025：
- Draft restructuring plan reached creditors, confirming 188.07 billion yuan in total claims.
- October 17, 2025：
- Original vote deadline for the restructuring plan (later extended).
AI generated, for reference only
- PODCAST
- MOST POPULAR
Sign in with Google
Sign in with Facebook
Sign in with 财新