In Depth: How Middlemen Cash In on China’s Drive to Fund Young Entrepreneurs
Listen to the full version
When a student we’ll call Yu Dongdong returned to China to launch a jewelry design startup, she did what many young entrepreneurs do: she turned to social media for information about government subsidies available to recent graduates.
What she found were promises of “nearly 100% passing rates” for subsidy applications under “professional guidance” from specialized agencies. After signing a contract with one, she spent the next year discovering that the help she had paid for amounted to little more than template modifications and superficial packaging. The agency had also pressured her into renting office space from them — a requirement, they said, for qualifying for the subsidy — and assured her that a separate venue subsidy that never materialized would cover the cost.
Unlock exclusive discounts with a Caixin group subscription — ideal for teams and organizations.
Save an extra $50. Introductory offer for new readers. Subscribe now.
- RELATED
- DIGEST HUB
Digest Hub
Back
- Intermediary agencies in China exploit graduates seeking startup subsidies via social media promises of high success rates, charging fees (e.g., 2,800-6,880 yuan + 20% commission) and rent (e.g., Yu's 34,000 yuan).
- Hangzhou offers 50,000-200,000 yuan grants amid 17% youth unemployment and 12.7 million 2024 graduates; info gaps aid agencies.
- Services minimal (templates, superficial advice); recourse rare, regulators aware but inactive.
1. Yu Dongdong, a returning student launching a jewelry startup in China, sought government subsidies via social media and contracted an agency promising high success rates [para. 1]. The agency provided minimal help like template tweaks, pressured her to rent office space from them for 34,000 yuan ($5,007), and took fees and 20% commission, consuming nearly all her subsidy after a year [para. 2][para. 3].
2. This is typical amid China's booming subsidies for graduate entrepreneurs, spawning intermediary agencies that charge fees devouring subsidies via social media ads [para. 4]. With 12.7 million graduates entering a tough job market (youth unemployment ~17% in March), concerns rise over funds reaching middlemen [para. 5].
3. Policies like Hangzhou's 50,000-200,000 yuan grants plus rent support attract both entrepreneurs and agencies [para. 7][para. 8]. Yu paid 5,800 yuan for Ruifu's package (consulting + finance fees + 20% commission) and was steered to their rent [para. 9]. Wang Le paid 5,500 yuan + 10-15% to Maibo Technology [para. 10].
4. Agencies lure via social media "success stories" like "Returnee Ph.D. Gets 9.334 Million Yuan," shifting to WeChat with deadline pressure [para. 12][para. 13]. Official info is hard to find; even experts struggle [para. 14]. Studies show 40-57% miss benefits due to info gaps, 70% of Guangdong students unaware [para. 15].
5. Agencies project professionalism with fancy offices [para. 16]. But help is superficial: superficial advice, self-revisions, exaggerations for Yu [para. 18]; templates and AI-suspected plans for Wang, with errors [para. 19]. Agencies deny high fees/commissions when queried but quote 20% posing as clients [para. 20].
6. Blogger notes agencies overload clients, providing perfunctory aid near deadlines, exploiting info asymmetry [para. 21]. Recourse is limited: police see civil disputes; fees unrecoverable; fear of backlash [para. 23][para. 24]. Ruifu sued Liu Hao for unpaid commission but lost (10-20% on grants violates morals) [para. 25]. Another paid Ruifu 14,000 yuan under pressure despite independent application [para. 26].
7. Officials say no intermediaries needed, no fees; aware and coordinating, but no measures yet [para. 27].
- Ruifu
- Ruifu, a Hangzhou agency, charges entrepreneurs like Yu Dongdong 5,800 yuan packages plus 20% subsidy commissions for minimal guidance (templates, superficial advice). It pressures clients to rent office space from them (34,000 yuan), promising unfulfilled subsidies. Courts rejected Ruifu's commission lawsuits as violating public morals; clients report little real help.
- Maibo Technology
- Maibo Technology, a Hangzhou agency, charges entrepreneurs 5,500+ yuan upfront plus 10-20% subsidy commissions for "lectures and process tutoring." Clients like Wang Le report minimal help—templates, superficial edits, errors, and suspected AI-generated materials—contradicting claims of no fees. (48 words)
- MOST POPULAR
Sign in with Google
Sign in with Facebook
Sign in with 财新