1. A U.S. federal court has ordered businessman Tony Hu, his mother, and Patten Holdings to pay $72.84 million to two Chinese investors. [para. 1] The default judgment was entered by the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California on Nov. 15, following the defendants' repeated failure to comply with evidence production orders. [para. 2] The case illustrates how fabricated institutional endorsements and ineffective contractual safeguards drew $35.49 million into a cross-border deal for a little-known American university. [para. 3]
2. The investors, identified as Zhang and Chen, invested in July 2021 for a combined 39% stake in California's Patten University. [para. 4] Zhang committed $27.3 million through Bluestone Investment, while Chen invested $8.19 million via World Education Association. [para. 4] Hu's proposal promised a joint college with Stanford, a teaching center, and two laboratories in Shenzhen, along with exclusive student recruitment rights in China and the prospect of an initial public offering. [para. 5]
3. Hu supplied forged documents portraying Patten as profitable. [para. 6] A report bearing PwC's logo valued the university at over $51 million and recommended buying. [para. 6] A purported audit from Holthouse Carlin & Van Trigt reported 2019 revenue above $9 million and assets over $37 million, while an unaudited statement showed 2020 net revenue above $12 million and gross profit above $10 million. [para. 6] He also provided a 50-page due-diligence report and two purported Stanford agreements, one signed by then-president Marc Tessier-Lavigne. [para. 7] He arranged Zoom meetings with Patten administrators, including part-time associate dean William Sawyer and vice president Scott Ethan Victor. [para. 8] The court found the valuation, audit, due-diligence reports, and both Stanford agreements were forged, concluding that Hu secured the investment through fabricated documents, not merely unfulfilled promises. [para. 9]
4. The investment agreements required funds to remain in escrow until Patten provided formal cooperation documents signed by Stanford, and offered remedies such as a share buyback at no less than twice the purchase price if the IPO failed. [para. 11] However, the court found Hu controlled the purported escrow account. [para. 12] Investors later learned Hu and his mother also controlled the JPMorgan Chase accounts for the investment companies, arranged while pandemic restrictions prevented travel. [para. 13] By early 2023, neither the IPO nor the joint college existed; when Chen visited in June, she found no students or normal teaching activity. [para. 14] The university had announced plans to wind down operations in 2018, three years before the investment. [para. 15]
5. Zhang, Chen, and their companies filed suit in June 2025. [para. 17] From January through June 2026, the court issued five orders for evidence, which the defendants ignored. [para. 17] After a final warning on Oct. 2, the court dismissed their counterclaims on Oct. 15, leading to the default judgment. [para. 18] The court assessed losses at $24.28 million and awarded triple damages under California law, holding Hu, his mother, and Patten Holdings jointly liable. [para. 19] The loss calculation included a $150,000 withdrawal by Hu's mother and excluded $11.36 million transferred to Hong Kong to avoid a damages dispute. [para. 19]
6. The court dismissed claims against JPMorgan and a bank employee, finding insufficient evidence they intentionally assisted the fraud, despite awareness of unusual transactions or procedural lapses. [para. 20] Sawyer, who had signed share-purchase and IPO agreements, saw his claims initially proceed after a court ruling on Oct. 23, 2025. [para. 21] However, on Nov. 13, 2025, the investors voluntarily dismissed their claims against Sawyer and Patten University without stating reasons. [para. 21] The award does not guarantee repayment, as the defendants' assets and the extent of investor recovery remain unknown. [para. 22]
AI generated, for reference only