BYD's Wang Barrels Into Monorails After Conquering Batteries, Electric Vehicles
Listen to the full version
(Beijing) — BYD Co. is setting its sights on China's expanding monorail transport system, hoping to duplicate its success in the battery and electric-car businesses. But BYD faces challenges to its qualifications to engineer trains, the speed with which it has entered the market, and questions about the origins of its train designs.
Wang Chuanfu, BYD founder and chairman, is nonetheless barreling ahead. Outside the city of Shantou in the southern province of Guangdong, he is ready to begin construction Wednesday of a monorail factory in an idle field dominated by wild grass. The 56 billion yuan ($8.1 billion) project will be the first monorail facility for BYD, which is about 8% owned by Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway Inc.
Unlock exclusive discounts with a Caixin group subscription — ideal for teams and organizations.
Subscribe to both Caixin Global and The Wall Street Journal — for the price of one.
- RELATED
Digest Hub
Back
- BYD Co., known for its success in the electric car and battery market, is venturing into China's monorail sector with plans to build a factory in Guangdong and has already begun construction on a monorail line in Shenzhen. The company faces challenges including questions about its qualifications, the speed of market entry, and allegations of copying designs from competitors like Bombardier.
- The Chinese government's investment in public transportation infrastructure and the growing competition in the electric-auto market are driving BYD's pivot to monorails, which are seen as a more affordable public transit option compared to subways. BYD aims to leverage this shift to double its size, despite concerns over technology development speed and obtaining necessary certifications.
- Bombardier has accused BYD of patent infringement, highlighting similarities between BYD's prototype train and its own products. This raises potential legal challenges for BYD amidst its aggressive expansion into the monorail market, where it has already garnered interest from over 20 Chinese cities despite existing uncertainties regarding business licensing and product standards.
BYD Co., a company initially known for its battery and electric-car businesses, is venturing into China's monorail transport system amidst the country's push to expand its public transportation infrastructure. Despite facing skepticism regarding its rapid entry into the market and the originality of its train designs, BYD is moving forward with significant investments in this sector [para. 1][para. 2]. The company, partly owned by Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway Inc., plans to start construction of a monorail factory in Guangdong province, marking its first foray into monorail manufacturing. This venture comes at a time when competition in the electric-auto market is intensifying, and government support for electric carmakers is waning [para. 2][para. 3].
Wang Chuanfu, BYD's founder and chairman, has ambitious plans for the company's expansion into rail transportation, aiming to double BYD's size. The company has already initiated projects such as the "SkyRail" plan in Shenzhen and signed agreements with various city governments for monorail construction [para. 4][para. 5]. Monorails are seen as a more affordable option compared to subways but have lower passenger capacities. Historically, only a few cities globally have adopted monorails for their urban networks [para. 6].
BYD faces competition from established players like Japan's Hitachi Ltd. and Canada's Bombardier Inc., which have decades of experience in monorail technology. However, BYD claims that developing monorail technology is simpler than perceived and asserts that it has invested significantly in research and development over the past five years [para. 7][para. 8]. Despite challenges such as obtaining government certification due to China not having compulsory national standards for rail equipment yet, BYD remains optimistic about its prospects in winning bids for monorail projects across Chinese cities [para. 9][para. 10].
The company's rapid progress has raised eyebrows within the industry, with some questioning how BYD developed its technology so quickly. There are also concerns about potential intellectual property issues, as Bombardier has accused BYD of patent infringements related to its prototype train design and technologies. While BYD insists that its SkyRail system is self-developed without imported technology, legal experts note that imitation and infringement are distinct concepts under law [para. 11][para. 12]. The outcome of these allegations remains uncertain but poses a potential risk to BYD’s ambitions in the monorail market.
In summary, BYD is aggressively pursuing opportunities within China’s burgeoning monorail sector despite facing challenges related to market entry speed, technological originality concerns, and potential legal hurdles regarding intellectual property rights. With substantial investments planned and several projects underway or in negotiation stages across various Chinese cities, BYD aims to leverage this initiative to significantly grow its business footprint beyond its traditional automotive focus [para. 1]-[para. 12].
- BYD Co.
- Summay： BYD Co., founded by Wang Chuanfu, is a Chinese company that has successfully expanded from its origins in the cellphone battery business to become a major player in the automobile industry, particularly in the manufacturing of electric cars. It is approximately 8% owned by Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway Inc.BYD is now setting its sights on the monorail transport system market in China. The company has initiated several projects, including the construction of a monorail factory in an idle field in Shantou, Guangdong province, with an investment of 56 billion yuan ($8.1 billion). This is part of its "SkyRail" plan, under which it has also started building a 5.4-km electric monorail line connecting its headquarters in Shenzhen with a nearby high-speed railway station.The company is moving into the monorail sector at a time when competition in the electric auto market is increasing and the Chinese government is cracking down on subsidy abuses while reducing financial support for electric carmakers. However, the Chinese government's plan to invest heavily in public transportation infrastructure, including urban light-rail systems, offers opportunities for companies like BYD.BYD's monorail system is designed to be a more affordable option than subways, with the company claiming its system costs as little as one-sixth of an equivalent subway system. Despite the smaller passenger capacity of monorails, the company has received interest from over 20 Chinese cities for its monorail projects.The company's rapid entry into the monorail market has raised some industry eyebrows, with questions about the origins of its train designs and its qualifications to engineer trains. There are also concerns about whether BYD can obtain the necessary government certifications, as it is not one of the seven licensed train makers in China, all of which are state-owned.Bombardier, one of the world's largest monorail manufacturers, has accused BYD of patent infringement, claiming that BYD's prototype train bears great similarities to its own products. CRRC Puzhen Bombardier, a joint venture between Bombardier and Chinese train maker China South Railway Corp., has reportedly started collecting evidence to sue BYD.Despite these challenges, BYD maintains that its SkyRail system is 100% self-developed and that its technology is mature enough for commercial production. Wang Chuanfu aims to use the rail business to double the size of BYD, which had revenue of 80 billion yuan in the previous year.
- Hitachi Ltd.
- Summay： Hitachi Ltd. is mentioned in the article as one of the world's largest monorail manufacturers. The article discusses how Hitachi, along with Bombardier Inc., is a significant player in the monorail industry. It is noted that both companies spent decades developing their monorail technologies, which is contrasted with the relatively short time BYD Co. has taken to enter the market. The mention of Hitachi serves to emphasize the established nature of the monorail industry and the experience of its major players compared to the newcomer, BYD.
- Bombardier Inc.
- Summay： Bombardier Inc. is a Canadian multinational company that is a major player in the rail transportation equipment industry. It is one of the world's largest monorail manufacturers and has a strong presence in the global market. In the context of the article, Bombardier has entered into a joint venture with Chinese train maker China South Railway Corp., which later merged into China Railway Rolling Stock Group (CRRC). This joint venture, known as CRRC Puzhen Bombardier Transportation System Co., aims to promote monorail projects in China.Bombardier has accused BYD Co. of patent infringement, claiming that there are great similarities between its products and BYD's prototype monorail train. The company has alleged that BYD's "SkyRail" monorail system copied the design and key technologies from CRRC Puzhen Bombardier, including the automatic driving system and engine. As a result, Bombardier, through its joint venture, has hired lawyers and started collecting evidence to potentially sue BYD for patent infringement.
- China Railway Rolling Stock Group (CRRC)
- Summay： The China Railway Rolling Stock Corporation (CRRC) is the largest train manufacturer in the world, and it plays a significant role in the article. CRRC has been involved in the development and production of monorail systems, which are a focus of the article's narrative. CRRC has subsidiaries that are among the seven licensed train makers in China, and it is mentioned that six of these licensed train makers are CRRC subsidiaries.In the context of the article, CRRC is relevant in several ways:1. **Monorail Projects and Competition**: CRRC, through its joint venture with Bombardier, CRRC Puzhen Bombardier Transportation System Co., is a competitor to BYD in the monorail market. The joint venture has signed a deal to start construction of a monorail line in Wuhu city.2. **Licensing and Standards**: As a state-owned enterprise and a major player in the rail industry, CRRC's subsidiaries are subject to and comply with the national standards and certifications for rail equipment-making. The article suggests that BYD, as a non-state-owned entity, needs to go through strict assessments to obtain the necessary certifications to compete with CRRC in the rail market.3. **Technology and Accusations of Imitation**: CRRC-Bombardier has accused BYD of imitating its monorail technology, claiming that BYD's prototype train has great similarities to its own products. CRRC-Bombardier has reportedly hired lawyers and is collecting evidence to sue BYD for patent infringement.4. **Industry Standing**: The article implies that CRRC, with its established presence and long history in the rail industry, is a formidable competitor. The rapid progress of BYD into the monorail sector is contrasted with the decades that CRRC and Bombardier have spent developing their technologies.5. **Response to Market Demands**: While BYD is making a bold entry into the monorail market, CRRC is taking a more cautious approach, with a preference to convert existing rail-equipment factories for monorail production rather than building new ones, according to a CRRC source.CRRC's role in the article underscores the challenges that BYD faces in entering the monorail market and the established industry players that it must compete with.
- 1898：
- The first monorail for public transportation was built in Germany's industrial Ruhr district.
- 2006：
- The southwest Chinese city of Chongqing launched two monorail lines, built in partnership with Japanese companies.
- 2011：
- The southwest Chinese city of Chongqing launched two monorail lines, built in partnership with Japanese companies.
- September 2014：
- Bombardier set up a joint venture with Chinese train maker China South Railway Corp., which later merged into China Railway Rolling Stock Group (CRRC), to promote monorail projects in China.
- Mid-December：
- The venture, CRRC Puzhen Bombardier Transportation System Co., signed a deal with the Wuhu city government in Anhui province to start construction of a monorail line in early 2017 after more than two years of negotiation.
- March：
- BYD signaled its monorail ambitions when it set up a monorail division.
- June：
- Wang told a meeting of company shareholders that BYD was ready to tap into the light-rail market.
- October：
- BYD unveiled its prototype train and started a demonstration line inside its Shenzhen plant.
- Mid-November：
- The Xi'an city government in Shaanxi province announced an investment agreement with BYD, including a 2 billion yuan plant for monorail equipment and parts production.
- PODCAST
- MOST POPULAR
Sign in with Google
Sign in with Facebook
Sign in with 财新